Join Us All Season Long. Subscribe Today!

A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder

Murder and mayhem fuel this Tony-winning musical romp!
Runs:
Sep 11, 2026
-
Sep 27, 2026
Buy Tickets
Book and Lyrics:
Robert L. Freedman
Music & Lyrics:
Steven Lutvak
Based on the novel:
“Israel Rank” by Roy Horniman
Ages:
11+ (stylized violence & dark humor)
Preview Night:
Pick-Your-Price Night
Ticket Discounts:

After Preview Night for Seniors, Educators, Youth, & Active Military

Single Tickets:
7:30 PM Evenings:
Fridays and Saturdays
2:00 PM Matinees:
Sundays and select Saturdays
Need wheelchair or companion seats? Contact the Box Office
Find answers to before, during, and after-show FAQs on our What to Expect page.

A GENTLEMAN’S GUIDE TO LOVE AND MURDER is the uproarious, Tony-winning hit of 2014, sweeping Best Musical, Book, Direction, and Costumes, plus multiple Drama Desk, Outer Critics Circle, and Drama League Awards. When low-born Monty Navarro learns he’s eighth in line for an earldom, he embarks on a darkly comic mission to remove his unsuspecting relatives—and maybe win love along the way. Packed with unforgettable music, nonstop laughs, and one actor playing all eight doomed heirs, this murderous romp is a fresh, original comedy that audiences can’t get enough of!

A GENTLEMAN’S GUIDE TO LOVE AND MURDER is made possible thanks to the generous support of Show Sponsors The McClammy Family. Special thanks to Role Players Marda Buchholz and Marcie Brown for their support of A GENTLEMAN’S GUIDE TO LOVE AND MURDER creative team.

Your name could be HERE! For information about named production support please contact Artistic Director, Patrick Klein or visit paplayers.org/production-sponsorships.

“Inspired and hilarious!”The New York Times

Subscribe to get tickets to this and other 2026-27 season shows!

Special events taking place during the run include:
Preview Night: Pick-Your-Price
Friday, October 30, 2026

Pick-Your-Price Night makes theatre affordable for all. Choose from three ticket price suggestions.

Opening Night
Saturday, September 12, 2026

Enjoy a post-show champagne/sparkling cider toast in the outdoor courtyard, FREE with the purchase of a ticket for that evening’s performance.

Post-Show Cast Talkback
Sunday, September 20, 2026

Enrich your experience at our Talkback series with the director and the cast following the performance, FREE with the purchase of a ticket for any performance during the run.

Creative & Production Team

Director & Choreographer: Lee Ann Payne
Music & Vocal Director: Tony Gaitan
Scenic Designer: Patrick Klein
Costume Designer: Hal DuBiel
Fight Director:
Lighting Designer: Raven Manalo
Sound Designer:
Chris Beer
Hair/Makeup Designer: Karen Althoff
Sound Supervisor:
Jeff Grafton
Properties Designer:
Greet Jaspaert
Stage Manager: Cayleigh Spikes
Assistant Stage Manager: Joel Best
Costume Assistant: Lisa Rozman
Dialect Coach:
Technical Director & Master Carpenter: Kevin Davies
Master Electrician: Darbus Oldham

Cast Members

Monty Navarro: Andrew Cope
Phoebe D’Ysquith: Chesny Evert
Sibella Hallward: Brenna Silva
Miss Shingle: Sarah Jebian
D’Ysquith Family: Brandon Savage
Featured Player: Milovan Bogdanic
Featured Player: Corinna Laskin (Movement Captain)
Featured Player: Alea Selburn
Featured Player: David Murphy
Featured Player: Patrick Rivera
Featured Player: Vanessa Alvarez
Featured Player: Jackson Paddock
Featured Player: Sam Kim

Group Tickets

Bringing a group? Save when you book together.

Contact The Box Office